HabsWorld.net --
The Montreal Canadiens are just past the first quarter mark of this season, and the time for HabsWorld writers to grade players is back. The first in this two-part series will focus on the goaltenders and defencemen.
Goalies
Jacob Fowler: Grade A
Thank God for Montreal Canadiens scout Billy Ryan, who was such a strong advocate of Fowler as a USHL player Montreal needed to draft in the summer of 2023. The Habs watched while five other goaltenders were picked ahead of him, all in the second round, then pounced on him early in the third round. This fall, the team’s management decided to send Jacob down to the AHL to start the season, and give veteran Samuel Montembeault the backup spot with Jakub Dobes landing the starter’s role. An injury during practice last month sidelined Montembeault and opened the door for Fowler, who has seized the number one role. Fowler’s strong play to start this season has given Montreal the netminder they desperately needed. That has also garnered Calder Trophy talk among hockey writers and podcasters recently. His unflappable demeanor and his minimalistic style has started to garner comparisons to Canadiens legend Carey Price.
Stats: 13 GP, 2.21 GAA, 0.923 SV%, 9-2-2 Record, 2 Shutouts
Jakub Dobes: Grade D
The hero of last spring’s playoff run for the Canadiens, Dobes has struggled mightily to start this regular season. While Dobes played very well to end last season, he has not returned to the same level at all. Nearly every goal against him looks bad, and most of them look stoppable. It’s possible that his postseason got the attention of the coaching staffs of the other 31 NHL teams, and now they have a “book” on how to shoot against Dobes. However, I am not seeing a specific pattern to the goals he has let in. He’s been erratic, but his style of play was similar last season too. For now, he has been relegated to the backup role not only because of his struggles but due to the excellent play of teammate Jacob Fowler.
Stats: 8 GP, 3.93 GAA, 0.852 SV%, 3-3-2 Record
Defencemen
Lane Hutson: Grade A+
I am starting to run out of superlatives to describe Habs superstar Lane Hutson each time I sit down to write these articles for HabsWorld. Once again, Lane leads all defencemen in points this quarter. This time he also leads them in goals and shots on goal, a sign he has gained confidence in his shot. That’s a big sign of improvement compared to his rookie season in 2024-25. Without veteran Mike Matheson, Lane’s ice time has gone up more. To add to Lane’s assault on Canadiens records, on October 27 in a game against St. Louis, he set a new team record for most assists (136) before the age of 23. Habs legend Henri Richard had the previous record of 135.
Stats: 21 GP, 3 G, 16 A, 19 PTS, 10 PIMS, +4, 43 Shots, 5 Hits, 30 Blocked Shots, 25:05 ATOI
Kaiden Guhle: Grade B+
After Guhle missed the first four games of this season recovering from offseason adductor muscle surgery, he stepped right into the lineup like he had not missed training camp and the exhibition games. A healthy Kaiden is a welcome sight for this team, since he arguably has the best combination of offensive skills and toughness on the squad. I cannot say he is better defensively than Lane Hutson, but he is more of a physical presence. One of his best games this season was the Outdoor Classic game in Winnipeg on November 7th. Not only did he score the game-winning goal, but he played a strong defensive game with a physical edge.
Stats: 17 GP, 2 G, 4 A, 6 PTS, 10 PIMS, +7, 43 Shots, 42 Hits, 31 Blocked Shots, 22:39 ATOI
Arber Xhekaj: Grade B
Arber started this season struggling somewhat. He was often paired with Jayden Struble on the third duo, but with both defencemen being left-handed shots, it was far from ideal for both players. After Struble was traded to Nashville, his usual partner was Alexander Carrier but those two players never really gelled. In eight of the last nine games of the quarter, Arber and Adam Engstrom were steady partners, and both players appear to be blossoming. In particular, Xhekaj has been settling down his physical style somewhat, reducing the times he is the aggressor. During the November 14 game against the New York Rangers, their enforcer Matt Rempe challenged Arber multiple times but he did not take the bait and put his fellow blueliners down a man. He still leads the defencemen in penalty minutes and hits, but a few calls against him appear to have been given due to his reputation more than his detrimental play. In recent games, Xhekaj has also been given penalty-killing duties. During those times, his physicality in front of the net is an advantage in tying up opponents efficiently. With his growing confidence on the ice, Arber has also surprised opponents in the offensive zone with carrying the puck to the net to generate scoring chances.
Stats: 20 GP, 1 G, 3 A, 4 PTS, 32 PIMS, +1, 17 Shots, 41 Hits, 15 Blocked Shots, 12:13 ATOI
Adam Engstrom: Grade B
During exhibition games this year, I thought it was going to be a close decision between keeping Engstrom or David Reinbacher. I thought the latter had a slight edge in play, but management weighed several factors into their call to keep Engstrom up on the NHL squad. It still took until game four for him to get into the lineup. Although Adam was a healthy scratch for seven games to start this season, he has made steady progress. After the injury to Mike Matheson and the trade of Jayden Struble, he got the opportunity to play. As a rookie, he has made a few mistakes, but I have not seen any of them repeated which is a good sign he’s a quick learner. As mentioned above, when he got partnered with Xhekaj on the third pairing, his game started to grow. One of his strengths is his ability to play the right side even though he’s a left shot; several veterans cannot handle that type of assignment well. He is a good skater with some offensive passing and shooting skills. What has impressed me are the subtle times he has defended a man one-on-one and made a smart play with his stick or body to break up the play. For a young player, that’s impressive, and I hope it’s a sign of good things to come.
Stats: 14 GP, 1 G, 1 A, 2 PTS, 2 PIMS, +6, 13 Shots, 2 Hits, 8 Blocked Shots, 11:35 ATOI
Alexandre Carrier: Grade B
Going into training camp, Carrier mentioned that he has had one conversation with GM Kent Hughes about his future in Montreal with free agency potentially coming up next summer. A Quebec native with a young family and his wife being a doctor, I am sure he would prefer to stay in town instead of leaving. So far, he has produced offensively; he is third on the team in points among blueliners and second in plus/minus. His defensive game has been steady. Carrier leads Habs blueliners in blocked shots, and has played on all three pairings at different times this year. As a smaller player, he gets outmuscled during one-on-one battles often enough. With right-shot defencemen like David Reinbacher and Russian Bogdan Konyushkov signed for next season for lower salaries, the writing may be on the wall for Carrier’s career to not continue in Montreal for 2027-28.
Stats: 21 GP, 1 G, 6 A, 7 PTS, 14 PIMS, +6, 16 Shots, 19 Hits, 39 Blocked Shots, 20:19 ATOI
Mike Matheson: Grade B
It’s been a troubling start for the veteran this season. For the first four games, he was partnered with Noah Dobson; the duo was generally given shutdown duties for most of last season. After the fifth game, Matheson missed the next four games with a lower-body injury. After returning, he seemed to be struggling a bit. He played three games then returned back to the injured list with what appears to be the same injury, indicating that he came back too soon. After missing six games, he returned to play on November 12th against Boston, then was injured again and has not yet returned. The team is managing without him, but his usual partner Dobson would likely improve his play when Matheson does return and stays in the lineup. When healthy, Mike uses his strong skating abilities well in a defensive role, and can still chip in a few points from time to time.
Stats: 9 GP, 1 G, 4 A, 5 PTS, 6 PIMS, +4, 16 Shots, 5 Hits, 16 Blocked Shots, 23:28 ATOI
Noah Dobson: Grade C+
Noah is also off to a strong start this season. With Lane Hutson as his partner, the duo has formed the most frequent pairing in terms of ice time. His offensive stats are also good, second behind his partner Hutson in goals, assists, points, and shots on goal. What is troubling to me, is while Dobson is only 26 years old and is in his eighth NHL season, he still makes fundamental defensive mistakes based on covering an opponent or decision-making without the puck. For a top-pairing blueliner in terms of his minutes and his salary, he would probably be better suited for a second-pairing role.
Stats: 21 GP, 0 G, 9 A, 9 PTS, 16 PIM, -3, 42 Shots, 22 Hits, 29 Blocked Shots, 20:59 ATOI
